Welcome

Website counter
website hit counter
website hit counters

Monday, February 14, 2011

Fwd: [bangla-vision] The Arabist on the Muslim Brotherhood



---------- Forwarded message ----------
From: Steven Robinson <srobin21@comcast.net>
Date: Mon, Feb 14, 2011 at 1:47 AM
Subject: [bangla-vision] The Arabist on the Muslim Brotherhood

 

Regarding the Brotherhood

By Issandr El Amrani
The Arabist
February 13, 2011

Ever since the beginning of the uprising in Egypt, I have been urged to
address the issue of the Muslim Brotherhood. I have not done so to make a
point: it just was not that important in the phase that just ended, leading
to the resignation of Hosni Mubarak. There were more urgent matters at hand,
and the alarmism over the Brotherhood we see in many publications was
largely silly.

They were not a part of the uprising's beginning, distancing themselves from
it initially, and while the Ikhwan youth ended up being a key part of the
Tahrir coordinating committee, this is different then the leadership having
a key role. Indeed, the Youth and leadership parted at various points over
the last week, and I have been told that at one point the Youth refused a
direct order from the leadership to move away from tanks (which they, along
with others, were blocking by lying underneath them.) Only a few days ago
the Ikhwan Youth were telling me that their solidarity with the other youth
groups in Tahrir was more important than a leadership they've had problems
with fir five years. And, when the MB was given an unprecedented offer by
the teetering regime of a seat around the negotiation table, it joined in
when others - include all the Tahrir groups and ElBaradei's National
Association for Change - refused. I don't agree with some people's view that
the new Egyptian political reality irrelevant, but like other opposition
groups it will have to account - internally and to the public - for its
initial hesitation. Personally, there is little doubt in my mind that the MB
leadership would have cut a deal with the regime if it thought it could get
away with it.

That being said, the issue of the Brotherhood is important for Egypt's
future, and there is plenty for some people to be concerned about. The MB is
quite well placed to take advantage of a political opening in Egypt, with
its track record at electoral canvassing, a decent national organization
with a robust administrative framework, a well-known message and many
reputable personalities. As Helena Cobban notes, it is also perhaps the
political force in Egypt with the best PR, domestically and internationally,
having placed two op-eds into the major American papers today:

PR is not everything, though. These two men, al-Erian and Abou el-Fotouh,
are the image the MB wants to give to the outside world: accomplished
professionals, great syndicate organizers, and people who describe
themselves as "reformists." In Abou el-Fotouh's case, he deserves this
accolade - he has a track record of intellectual integrity and openness. But
he could not keep himself on the Guidance Council in the last elections,
which tells you a lot about his position within the MB. Al-Erian, after
years of being ignored because a) he speaks too much and b) he wanted it too
much, was elected to the Guidance Council in what appeared to be a deal with
the conservative leadership. Al-Erian is a great political operative, but
one whose values are flexible to say the least. Having interviewed him many
times, I have often wonders whether he believes in what he says and how much
it is shared by others in the MB.

The MB is a big tent, it includes people with a lot of different views. The
whole sad episode of its draft program a few years ago showed that there are
strong disagreements within the organization on doctrine, and in the last
two years a growing disagreement on methods, notably whether it was worth
paying the price of political participation when the movement's core aim is
the Islamization of society from below. Its swing back in an
ultra-conservative direction after the opening that took place under the
innovative if haphazard leadership of General Guide Muhammad Akef was
largely a reaction, and perhaps a concession, to the regime. The Egyptian
revolution that has just taken place will also have an impact on leadership
and rank-and-file, particularly since they have a shot at their political
activity being legitimized and legalized for the first time.

But that does not mean it will be easily able to resolve the debates that
have raged over the last few years. In my opinion, the MB should be made to
register as a civil society group and provide information as to its
financing. Should - as I hope - partisan life in Egypt be reformed and the
obstacles to political party formation removed, its political wing will be
able to form a party. Hopefully they might form several parties, with
perhaps some joining forces with the Wasat movement and others forming a
more conservative party. Likewise reformed Gamaa Islamiya members will be
able to form a party, or perhaps join other formations. That's assuming -
and it's a big if at this point - that the ban on religious parties the
regime had imposed is lifted. Most likely, some sort of compromise will be
found: a new national consensus that can leave room for Islamist politicians
and also address the quite understandable fears many have about Islamists
reaching power. I also hope that part of this trade-off is a secular
constitution, although that's unlikely. A lot will depend on the new red
lines that emerge from the army, and the extent to which the transition
process progresses smoothly.

As it stands, the Muslim Brotherhood is one of the most intellectually
un-evolved major Islamist movements in the Arab world. Practically everyone
of its offshoots has devised mechanisms for separating proselytization and
politics, and has had the opportunity of having a richer intellectual debate
about it means to be an Islamists in the 21st century. The MB, like most
opposition groups in Egypt, took on some of the attributes of the regime:
sclerosis, gerontocracy, authoritarian tendencies, lack of vision, and more.
They were taken by surprise by Kifaya in 2005 and by the revolt in 2011.
Their major advance in recent years was their public attachment to democracy
and pluralism, but that was when it seemed like a distant possibility. They
now need to reassess and more clearly communicate what they stand for in
post-25 January Egypt. There will have to be a lot of house-cleaning.

http://www.arabist.net/blog/2011/2/13/regarding-the-brotherhood.html

This email was cleaned by emailStripper, available for free from
http://www.papercut.biz/emailStripper.htm

__._,_.___


--
Palash Biswas
Pl Read:
http://nandigramunited-banga.blogspot.com/

No comments:

मैं नास्तिक क्यों हूं# Necessity of Atheism#!Genetics Bharat Teertha

হে মোর চিত্ত, Prey for Humanity!

मनुस्मृति नस्ली राजकाज राजनीति में OBC Trump Card और जयभीम कामरेड

Gorkhaland again?আত্মঘাতী বাঙালি আবার বিভাজন বিপর্যয়ের মুখোমুখি!

हिंदुत्व की राजनीति का मुकाबला हिंदुत्व की राजनीति से नहीं किया जा सकता।

In conversation with Palash Biswas

Palash Biswas On Unique Identity No1.mpg

Save the Universities!

RSS might replace Gandhi with Ambedkar on currency notes!

जैसे जर्मनी में सिर्फ हिटलर को बोलने की आजादी थी,आज सिर्फ मंकी बातों की आजादी है।

#BEEFGATEঅন্ধকার বৃত্তান্তঃ হত্যার রাজনীতি

अलविदा पत्रकारिता,अब कोई प्रतिक्रिया नहीं! पलाश विश्वास

ভালোবাসার মুখ,প্রতিবাদের মুখ মন্দাক্রান্তার পাশে আছি,যে মেয়েটি আজও লিখতে পারছেঃ আমাক ধর্ষণ করবে?

Palash Biswas on BAMCEF UNIFICATION!

THE HIMALAYAN TALK: PALASH BISWAS ON NEPALI SENTIMENT, GORKHALAND, KUMAON AND GARHWAL ETC.and BAMCEF UNIFICATION! Published on Mar 19, 2013 The Himalayan Voice Cambridge, Massachusetts United States of America

BAMCEF UNIFICATION CONFERENCE 7

Published on 10 Mar 2013 ALL INDIA BAMCEF UNIFICATION CONFERENCE HELD AT Dr.B. R. AMBEDKAR BHAVAN,DADAR,MUMBAI ON 2ND AND 3RD MARCH 2013. Mr.PALASH BISWAS (JOURNALIST -KOLKATA) DELIVERING HER SPEECH. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oLL-n6MrcoM http://youtu.be/oLL-n6MrcoM

Imminent Massive earthquake in the Himalayas

Palash Biswas on Citizenship Amendment Act

Mr. PALASH BISWAS DELIVERING SPEECH AT BAMCEF PROGRAM AT NAGPUR ON 17 & 18 SEPTEMBER 2003 Sub:- CITIZENSHIP AMENDMENT ACT 2003 http://youtu.be/zGDfsLzxTXo

Tweet Please

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...

THE HIMALAYAN TALK: PALASH BISWAS BLASTS INDIANS THAT CLAIM BUDDHA WAS BORN IN INDIA

THE HIMALAYAN TALK: INDIAN GOVERNMENT FOOD SECURITY PROGRAM RISKIER

http://youtu.be/NrcmNEjaN8c The government of India has announced food security program ahead of elections in 2014. We discussed the issue with Palash Biswas in Kolkata today. http://youtu.be/NrcmNEjaN8c Ahead of Elections, India's Cabinet Approves Food Security Program ______________________________________________________ By JIM YARDLEY http://india.blogs.nytimes.com/2013/07/04/indias-cabinet-passes-food-security-law/

THE HIMALAYAN TALK: PALASH BISWAS TALKS AGAINST CASTEIST HEGEMONY IN SOUTH ASIA

THE HIMALAYAN VOICE: PALASH BISWAS DISCUSSES RAM MANDIR

Published on 10 Apr 2013 Palash Biswas spoke to us from Kolkota and shared his views on Visho Hindu Parashid's programme from tomorrow ( April 11, 2013) to build Ram Mandir in disputed Ayodhya. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=77cZuBunAGk

THE HIMALAYAN TALK: PALASH BISWAS LASHES OUT KATHMANDU INT'L 'MULVASI' CONFERENCE

अहिले भर्खर कोलकता भारतमा हामीले पलाश विश्वाससंग काठमाडौँमा आज भै रहेको अन्तर्राष्ट्रिय मूलवासी सम्मेलनको बारेमा कुराकानी गर्यौ । उहाले भन्नु भयो सो सम्मेलन 'नेपालको आदिवासी जनजातिहरुको आन्दोलनलाई कम्जोर बनाउने षडयन्त्र हो।' http://youtu.be/j8GXlmSBbbk

THE HIMALAYAN DISASTER: TRANSNATIONAL DISASTER MANAGEMENT MECHANISM A MUST

We talked with Palash Biswas, an editor for Indian Express in Kolkata today also. He urged that there must a transnational disaster management mechanism to avert such scale disaster in the Himalayas. http://youtu.be/7IzWUpRECJM

THE HIMALAYAN TALK: PALASH BISWAS CRITICAL OF BAMCEF LEADERSHIP

[Palash Biswas, one of the BAMCEF leaders and editors for Indian Express spoke to us from Kolkata today and criticized BAMCEF leadership in New Delhi, which according to him, is messing up with Nepalese indigenous peoples also. He also flayed MP Jay Narayan Prasad Nishad, who recently offered a Puja in his New Delhi home for Narendra Modi's victory in 2014.]

THE HIMALAYAN TALK: PALASH BISWAS CRITICIZES GOVT FOR WORLD`S BIGGEST BLACK OUT

THE HIMALAYAN TALK: PALASH BISWAS CRITICIZES GOVT FOR WORLD`S BIGGEST BLACK OUT

THE HIMALAYAN TALK: PALSH BISWAS FLAYS SOUTH ASIAN GOVERNM

Palash Biswas, lashed out those 1% people in the government in New Delhi for failure of delivery and creating hosts of problems everywhere in South Asia. http://youtu.be/lD2_V7CB2Is

THE HIMALAYAN TALK: PALASH BISWAS LASHES OUT KATHMANDU INT'L 'MULVASI' CONFERENCE

अहिले भर्खर कोलकता भारतमा हामीले पलाश विश्वाससंग काठमाडौँमा आज भै रहेको अन्तर्राष्ट्रिय मूलवासी सम्मेलनको बारेमा कुराकानी गर्यौ । उहाले भन्नु भयो सो सम्मेलन 'नेपालको आदिवासी जनजातिहरुको आन्दोलनलाई कम्जोर बनाउने षडयन्त्र हो।' http://youtu.be/j8GXlmSBbbk